Choosing the right exterior shutters is not just about looks—it is about durability, maintenance, and how well the material performs over time. Homeowners today have several options, but three of the most popular choices are fiberglass exterior shutters, cedar wood exterior shutters, and PVC shutters. Each material has its own advantages and limitations, making it important to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision.
Fiberglass shutters: durability meets performance
Fiberglass has become a top choice for exterior shutters due to its strength and resistance to environmental stress.
Pros
- Exceptional durability: Fiberglass resists warping, cracking, and swelling, even in areas with extreme weather.
- Low maintenance: Unlike wood, fiberglass requires minimal upkeep—no need for frequent painting or sealing.
- Customizable finishes: These shutters can be painted to match your home’s exterior, giving you flexibility in design.
- Weather resistance: They hold up well against moisture, humidity, and insects.
Cons
- Higher cost: Fiberglass shutters are usually more expensive upfront compared to other options.
- Weight: They can be heavier than PVC shutters, requiring stronger installation support.
If you want long-term performance and minimal maintenance, fiberglass exterior shutters are worth the investment.
Cedar shutters: timeless natural appeal
Cedar has been used for centuries in construction, and when it comes to shutters, its natural beauty and durability make it a classic choice.
Pros
- Aesthetic value: Cedar offers a warm, rich, and authentic appearance that enhances curb appeal.
- Natural resistance: It naturally resists insects and decay better than many other wood types.
- Custom design: Easy to carve, cut, and customize into different shutter styles.
- Eco-friendly option: Cedar is a renewable resource and biodegradable.
Cons
- Maintenance required: Cedar shutters need regular sealing or painting to maintain their look and protect them from weather damage.
- Vulnerability to warping: If left untreated, cedar can warp or crack over time.
- Higher upkeep cost: While beautiful, they demand more care compared to fiberglass and PVC.
For homeowners who prioritize traditional beauty and do not mind maintenance, cedar wood exterior shutters remain a timeless option.
PVC shutters: affordability and ease
PVC, or vinyl shutters, are popular for their budget-friendly price and ease of use.
Pros
- Cost-effective: PVC shutters are typically the least expensive option.
- Moisture resistant: They do not absorb water, making them ideal for humid climates.
- Low maintenance: Easy to clean and does not require painting or sealing.
- Lightweight: Easier to install compared to heavier materials like fiberglass.
Cons
- Less authentic look: While designed to mimic wood, PVC shutters often lack the natural appeal of real cedar.
- Durability concerns: Over time, vinyl can fade, crack, or become brittle, especially under strong sunlight.
- Limited customization: They cannot be refinished or easily repainted.
PVC shutters are best for those seeking an affordable, low-maintenance solution without prioritizing long-term durability.
Making the right choice
When deciding between fiberglass, cedar, and PVC shutters, consider your priorities. If durability and low maintenance are at the top of your list, fiberglass exterior shutters are the strongest contender. For homeowners who value authentic beauty and do not mind regular upkeep, cedar wood exterior shutters provide timeless appeal. PVC shutters, on the other hand, offer a budget-friendly and practical option, though they may not last as long as the other two.
